BY Elizabeth Reid
Contributing Writer, Delta Business Journal
Proposed legislation that would have created
a state department of labor died in committee March 7, a move opponents
to the bill said saved Delta taxpayers thousands of dollars.
Proponents of Senate Bill 2668, which
would have created the Mississippi Department of Labor-Management Relations
by July 1, 2001, said consolidation of numerous functions from other areas
of state government under a single agency in Mississippi, the only state
they say that does not have a labor department, would be cost-efficient
and could result in increased federal funding for workforce training dollars.
Others disagree.
"Legislation as comprehensive as a state
department of labor is something that we should study long and hard before
its passage," said Griffin Norquist, chairman of the Delta Council and
president of the Bank of Yazoo City.
Governor Ronnie Musgrove, who supported the new
state department and will likely see it as an agenda item in next year's
legislative session, said Mississippi had to return more than $50 million
in federal funds because of the absence of a state labor department. Others
said the funds - namely, Welfare to Work money - were returned because
available TANF funding was sufficient.
According to an interdepartmental memo,
the Welfare to Work funding would have flowed through the JTPA or ES funding
system and would not have required any additional infrastructure. The money
was not lost because we did not have a system in place, but was turned
back for lack of interest.
Before the legislative motion died, Musgrove
had repeated his position at an annual AFL-CIO convention.
Thomas E. Lord, executive director of the Mississippi
Employment Security Commission, said parts of the bill had merit, such
as "combining training functions that need consolidating," he said
Consolidating workforce training dollars
and giving employees one place to go to file a complaint could be done
in a simpler way than forming a state labor department, said John Baas,
director of industrial relations for the Mississippi Manufacturers Association
Opponents to the bill said a layer of
unnecessary bureaucracy with regulatory burdens at a cost to state taxpayers
would be created. It would consist of a governor-appointed director and
five appointed commission members over five agencies - employment security,
workplace safety and health, job development and training, employee relations
and job discrimination and disabled employee assistance.
"It seems clear that legislative leadership
felt the same way," he said. "While we agree that consolidation of programs
is generally a way to operate more efficiently, we must be very careful
before we do anything that would dilute our status as a Right to Work state."